Velcro or Poppers? Choosing the Best Fastening for your Dog's Nappy

  • , by Vyctoria Brock
  • 6 min reading time
Velcro or Poppers? Choosing the Best Fastening for your Dog's Nappy

When choosing a dog nappy, season pants or male dog belly band, getting the right size is important, but have you considered which fastening will work best for your dog?

At Glenndarcy, we offer reusable dog nappies and belly bands with two fastening options: adjustable Velcro or secure poppers.

Both have advantages, and the best choice often depends on your dog’s body shape, coat type and individual needs.

We’ve been designing practical dog nappies and belly bands since 2011, and we’ve learned that even small details, such as the type of fastening, can make a difference to everyday comfort and convenience.

Velcro vs Poppers: What’s the Difference?

Velcro Fastenings

Popper Fastenings

Quick and easy to fasten and remove

Secure fastening with defined adjustment positions

Flexible adjustment around the waist

Useful for dogs with long or fluffy coats or stocky body

Often helpful for unusual body shapes

Less likely to catch or pull long fur

Useful for narrow waists or sloping backs

May be more difficult for some dogs to undo

Can collect loose fur and debris over time

Easy to keep clean and free from trapped hair

 

Neither option is automatically better. It’s about finding the right fit for your dog.

When Might Velcro Be the Better Choice?

Velcro fastenings provide flexible adjustment, making them particularly useful when your dog’s measurements don’t fit neatly into standard sizes.

Consider Velcro if:

  • Your dog has a narrow waist or sloping back.
  • You need more flexibility when adjusting the waistband.
  • You prefer a fastening that can be opened and adjusted quickly.

Velcro can be especially practical for dogs with short, smooth coats, where there is less risk of hair becoming caught in the fastening.

However, long fur can sometimes become trapped, and regular cleaning may be needed to keep the fastening working effectively.

When Might Poppers Be the Better Choice?

Popper fastenings provide secure closure with several adjustment positions, depending on the individual product.

They can be particularly helpful for dogs with long or thick coats because there is no Velcro surface for loose hair to become caught in.

Consider poppers if:

  • Your dog has a long, fluffy or thick coat.
  • Your dog has a rounded or barrel-shaped body.
  • Your dog’s waist measurement changes noticeably between standing and sitting.
  • You find Velcro catches or pulls your dog’s hair.
  • You prefer a fastening that clicks securely into position.
  • Your dog sometimes manages to loosen ordinary fastenings.
  • You prefer a fastening that doesn’t collect as much loose fur or debris.

Some dogs may find poppers more difficult to undo themselves, although no fastening is completely dog-proof.

Important: If your dog regularly chews, damages or attempts to remove their nappy, always supervise them and reassess whether the garment is suitable.

Don’t Forget to Check the Fit While Sitting

Here’s something many owners don’t think about when measuring their dog.

A dog’s waist circumference can change considerably between standing and sitting.

This is particularly noticeable in some rounded or barrel-shaped dogs.

We recommend measuring your dog while standing naturally, then checking the measurement again while sitting.

If the circumference increases significantly, you may need a larger waistband or a design with greater adjustment to maintain a comfortable fit.

Remember to allow for the thickness of the absorbent pad too.

A properly fitted nappy should remain secure without digging into the body or restricting natural movement.

Frequently Asked Questions

 

How Do I Remove Hair and Debris from Velcro?

Over time, Velcro fastenings can collect loose fur, fluff and small pieces of debris, particularly during washing.

A fine-toothed comb or dog slicker brush can help remove trapped material.

Gently brush through the fastening to lift out hair and debris without damaging the fabric.

Regular cleaning can help maintain the fastening’s grip and extend the useful life of your dog nappy or belly band.

Can I Replace a Broken Popper or Add Additional Poppers?

Glenndarcy popper-fastening products use size T5 KAM plastic snaps.

Replacement snaps and fitting tools are available from craft suppliers and online retailers.

If you have the correct equipment, it may be possible to replace a damaged snap or make minor adjustments.

However, any modifications should be made carefully, as incorrect placement could affect the fit, comfort or strength of the fastening.

What’s the Best Way to Undo Poppers?

Always place your fingers as close to the popper as possible and gently separate the two halves.

Avoid pulling on the surrounding fabric, as repeated strain could damage the material or loosen the snap.

Are Poppers Better for Dogs with Long Hair?

They often can be.

Poppers don’t have the same tendency to catch loose hair during fastening and removal, making them a practical option for Pomeranians, Spitz breeds and other heavily coated dogs.

However, remember that the correct size and overall fit are just as important as the fastening style.

Are Poppers More Secure Overnight?

Some dogs may find poppers more difficult to loosen than Velcro, but this doesn’t mean a popper-fastening nappy is automatically suitable for overnight wear.

Any dog wearing a nappy needs regular checks, prompt pad changes and monitoring for skin irritation.

A wet or soiled nappy should never be left against the skin for prolonged periods.

Which Glenndarcy Fastening Should I Choose?

If your dog has an unusual body shape and you need maximum flexibility when adjusting the waistband, Velcro may be the more practical option.

If your dog has a long or fluffy coat and you want to avoid hair becoming caught in the fastening, poppers may be worth considering.

Whatever fastening you choose, always compare your dog’s measurements with the individual product size chart before ordering.

At Glenndarcy, we believe comfortable dog nappies should accommodate the dog wearing them, rather than expecting every dog to fit the same shape.

Explore our reusable female dog nappies, adjustable Flexi-Pants and male dog belly bands to find the most suitable fit for your dog.

Designed in Scotland by Glenndarcy since 2011.

 

 

 

 

Tags

Comments

  • Hi,I would just like to give credit where its due.This company is amazing.I have bought many products over the years for my rescue dogs.Products are well made, made to last.They wash great and come out like new,as well as doing the job they are made for.For people who haven’t used there product,please try you won’t be disappointed. Well done to all your team,for making the perfect product.Thank You from a happy customer. JAN.

    JA

    Jan Lewis

Leave a comment

Leave a comment


Glenndarcy Dog Care & Advice Centre